I remember, as a child, going to Mehlman’s Cafeteria with my grandparents. Any time we went out to eat with them, we went to a cafeteria. I remember there being a Young’s Cafeteria too. And they all seemed to be located south or east of where we lived. But my grandparents loved eating at cafeterias.

As I got older and more sophisticated (insert sarcasm here), dining at a cafeteria reminded me of being in school. I spent the beginning of my high school career eating the chef salad in the cafe (as we affectionately called it) , but never any of the entrees offered. And never ever would I eat the hot ham and cheese sandwich, simply because I had biology right before lunch my sophomore year. I could never eat the hot ham and cheese sandwich after dissecting the fetal pigs we worked on in class. In fact, it was that same year that I moved away from the chef salad (because of the ham), and just drank coffee at lunch and played euchre. And all because I had choices. I was free to choose, no salad, just coffee – black.
But my grandparents, they loved a good cafeteria. This was also something that my Dad came to appreciate. So when Lenora’s opened locally as a cafeteria in the old movie theater back in the 1990’s, it was a big deal, at least to my Dad it was. Still, at this point, over 25 years ago, I did not see the big deal about cafeterias. But as I am getting older, I can appreciate their appeal.

Cafeterias provide options, selection, choices, from a variety of entrees, soups, side dishes, and desserts. I mean at a really good cafeteria; the options are seemingly endless. Who doesn’t like choices? Who doesn’t like really deciding for themselves? You get to pick whatever you want! You want two or even three desserts, you can get them. On a high protein low carb diet, load up on the various meat offerings. Trying out vegetarianism, you can go that route too! Its like the al a carte menu in fine dining establishments, but you don’t get the sticker shock because you’re not going to pay $10 for a dish of peas.
I have chosen Catholicism as my religion. But being Catholic is not an al a carte menu. There are no cafeteria options. I will admit, early in my faith, I thought that it was. I thought I could pick and choose what I wanted to believe about Catholicism, how I wanted to practice Catholicism, and still be Catholic…still be a good Catholic. This included attending mass on my terms, not recognizing confession as necessary, thinking that premarital sex was no big deal, and even at one point thinking that it is a woman’s right to choose. But it doesn’t work that way. Catholicism is an all or nothing proposition. You don’t get to pick and choose what you like, what sounds good, what is easy, what works for you and be “your” kind of Catholic. You have to go all in with God.
So yes, I have a hard time with people who claim to be Catholic and be pro-choice. No, you cannot be both. Not possible. Quoting the Catechism of the Catholic Church, in paragraph 2270, it begins – “Human life must be respected and protected absolutely from the moment of conception. From the first moment of his existence, a human being must be recognized as having the rights of a person – among which is the inviolable right of every innocent being to life.” This is not something you can pick and choose. If you are Catholic, you cannot be pro-choice. Period.

And yes, I know this is a controversial topic, but if you are Catholic it is not up for debate. It is stated in black and white in the Catechism. There are no exceptions, no buts or what ifs. If you are Catholic, and if you claim to be a devout Catholic, as so many of our elected officials tout, you cannot be pro-choice. Period.

Does my stance or belief make me any better than someone who claims to be Catholic but also is pro-choice? Absolutely not. We are all sinners, we are all broken, we all struggle. Trust me when I say I have fallen or gotten lost more times than I can count. But there have been people there to help me back up or point me in the right direction, particularly when I was sorely misguided. But that is what we are supposed to do, help each other, guide each other, pray for each other. We are supposed to be helping one another get to heaven. Maybe, just maybe, this reflection will help somebody get back up, get on the right path, get to heaven. Maybe.
So today, don’t treat your relationship with God like a visit to the cafeteria, picking and choosing how you will serve and honor Him. Go all in. It’s demanding, it’s difficult, it’s vulnerable, it’s challenging, and sometimes it goes against what society tells us is acceptable. That’s where the trust comes in and that’s where is gets even harder and even more beautiful. So believe me when I say it’s worth it. And today please pray for me and I will continue to pray for you.
















